| 47 | Ruben van Bommel (Bristol City) |
| 37 | Steven Bergwijn (Exeter City) |
| 35 | Lautaro Martínez (Stoke City, 5 pens.) |
| 33 | Leandro Trossard (Birmingham City) |
| 32 | Semih Kiliçsoy (Stockport County, 1 pen.) |
| Daniel James (Doncaster Rovers) |
| 29 | Alexander Sørloth (Birmingham City, 2 pens.) |
| 28 | Mika Biereth (Lincoln City, 2 pens.) |
| 27 | Eddie Nketiah (Lincoln City, 2 pens.) |
| Mario Vrancic (Scunthorpe United) |