| 35 | Rodrigo Riquelme (Fleetwood Town) |
| 30 | Demarai Gray (Barnsley) |
| 27 | Carlton Morris (Fleetwood Town, 4 pens.) |
| 26 | Anthony Gordon (Blackburn Rovers) |
| Philip Zinckernagel (Peterborough Utd) |
| 25 | Mika Biereth (Sunderland, 2 pens.) |
| Gianluca Scamacca (Crewe Alexandra, 5 pens.) |
| Roberto Firmino Barbosa (Wigan Athletic, 2 pens.) |
| 24 | Tom Lawrence (Derby County) |
| Danel Sinani (Walsall) |
| Vincent Janssen (Swindon Town, 3 pens.) |
| 22 | Sorba Thomas (Huddersfield Town) |
| Caleb Ekuban (Walsall, 1 pen.) |