| 40 | Steve Mounié (Burton Albion, 7 pens.) |
| 35 | Folarin Balogun (Cheltenham Town) |
| 31 | Jaidon Anthony (Oldham Athletic) |
| 29 | Reda Khadra (Salford City) |
| Anthony Elanga (Shrewsbury Town) |
| 27 | Adam Idah (Morecambe, 3 pens.) |
| 25 | Ognjen Mudrinski (Port Vale, 5 pens.) |
| Brandon Thomas-Asante (Salford City, 4 pens.) |
| Lars-Jørgen Salvesen (Oldham Athletic, 4 pens.) |
| 24 | Karlan Grant (Charlton Athletic, 4 pens.) |
| Anthony Limbombe (Plymouth Argyle) |